Total$24.99
FROM OUR ETSY SHOP

Loved by real customers

4.9· 11,600+ reviews on Etsy

Read all reviews on Etsy
Customer photo of their custom card
★★★★★

I made a custom card of me and my husband for our one year anniversary. The card was beautiful, and I was so happy with the quality in how it turned out. We like getting each other cards for special occasions, and this time I wanted to be nerdy and punny and get him not just a card, but a pokemon style card! My husband cried and absolutely loved all the little details that were able to be customized onto the card. I love it too, and it's a great display piece in the living room! I highly recommend this seller, as the communication was fast, professional, and it shipped quickly and arrived safely. I love how it turned out and words can't express how happy we are! ♥️

SamanthaAug 23, 2026
Anniversary CardEtsy review
★★★★★

The customization process was very simple and I was happy with how the card came out! I recommend adding the prismatic layer on the card, it makes a great anniversary gift for someone who loves Pokemon or TCG’s!

BenjaminOct 30, 2026
Anniversary CardEtsy review
Customer photo of their custom card
★★★★★

I absolutely love how this card turned out! The quality is great, there were so many cute options to customize it, and it arrived so much faster than I expected! My boyfriend is planning to propose soon, and while I don’t know exactly when, I wanted to have a little something special to surprise him with when he does! I thought this would be such a cute way to do that, and I’m so happy with how it came out! I can’t wait to give it to him when the time comes :) Highly recommend this shop!

ArianaOct 23, 2026
Anniversary CardEtsy review
★★★★★

absolutely amazing. I cried when I opened it. it's perfect!!!!!! thank you!

Etsy buyerSep 10, 2026
Anniversary CardEtsy review
YOUR PHOTO, REIMAGINED

A little moment.
A forever kind of keepsake.

Every Paper Hearts card begins with a photo you love and ends as something you can hold onto.

PREMIUM32ptcard stock
MADE TO BE KEPT

Premium card quality, down to every detail.

Vivid color, beautifully crisp type, and a satisfying weight in your hand. This isn't a novelty print — it's a real collectible.

  • Thick, premium 32pt card stock
  • Vibrant, fade-resistant printing
  • Smooth, rounded collector edges
  • Optional holographic finishes
MADE FOR EVERY STORY

Perfect for...

Birthdays

Cake days, now collectible

Best Friends

Your favorite duo

Pets

The true household MVP

Holidays

The gift they won't see coming

Anniversaries

A love story in card form

Collectors

Something truly one of one